Editorials

Editorial: wsj.com, June 4, 2011

NAACP vs. Black Parents
Standing in the doorway to protect failed schools.

Here's  something you don't see everyday. Thousands of American blacks held a rally in  Harlem last week to protest . . . the NAACP.

The New York  state chapter of the civil rights organization and the United Federation of  Teachers, the local teachers union, have filed a lawsuit to stop the city from  closing 22 of Gotham's worst schools. The lawsuit also aims to block the city  from giving charter schools space to operate in buildings occupied by  traditional public schools.
 
Protesters at the  rally, which included parents and charter school operators like Geoffrey  Canada of the Harlem Children's Zone, urged the NAACP to withdraw from the  suit. But Hazel Dukes, president of the state NAACP chapter, is unpersuaded.  Using the kind of language more readily associated with past opponents of  black civil rights, Ms. Dukes said that critics of the lawsuit "can march and  have rallies all day long. . . . We will not respond."
 
What schoolhouses is  Ms. Dukes standing in the doorway to protect? Well, at the Academy for  Collaborative Education, one of the Harlem schools that the city wants to  close, only 3% of students were performing at grade level in English last  year, and only 9% in math. At Columbus High School in the Bronx, another  school slated for closure, the four-year graduation rate in 2009 was 40%,  versus a citywide average of 63%, and less than 10% of special education  students graduated on time.
 
The teachers union  wants to keep these abysmal schools open to preserve jobs for their members.  This is bad enough. But the union and NAACP also want to limit better  educational options for low-income families who can't afford private schools  and can't afford to move to an affluent neighborhood with decent public  schools. The union knows that in a place like New York City, where space is at  a premium, blocking charters from operating in public buildings will hamper  charter growth.
 
If the  lawsuit succeeds, the awful schools will remain open to damage another  generation of children. If you want to know why the NAACP has become  irrelevant to the lives of African-Americans, this typical display of moral  indifference to the plight of minority children is Exhibit A.  


Home :: News & Editorials :: Learn About Charter Schools :: Get Involved :: About WCSRC :: Contact Us